This week, Congress voted on H.R. 51, the Washington, DC Admission Act, which would make Washington, DC the 51st state. I voted no on this bill for many reasons.
The founding Fathers clearly defined in the Constitution that Washington, DC is to be a federal district, so it would not be beholden to the wishes of a single state. They would have been shocked by the idea of making the city that holds the seat of the Federal Government its own state. It is a government city with minimal agriculture, manufacturing, and natural resources.
With all its government jobs, it is a recession-proof city and should be one of the easiest in the nation to govern. But, how are they actually doing? Despite spending more money per pupil than any state except New York, The Nation’s Report Card indicated that Washington, DC tied for last in fourth grade reading scores, last in fourth grade writing scores, and last in eight grade reading, writing, and math scores. Additionally, the last time the city was given control of their own budget, the Federal Government had to step in and bail them out.
There are also more homeless individuals in Washington, DC than 29 states. Of cities with at least 250,000 people, Washington, DC has the sixth highest murder rate, which means that if the city was to become a state then it would immediately become the state with the highest murder rate in the country.
Another argument is that residents of the city do not have Congressional representation. This is untrue. Washington, DC has one elected Congressional delegate, whose constituency is about the same size as a single Congressional district, so Washingtonians are not being disproportionately represented.
The motive for the 51st state push seems to be political instead of practical, since if Washington, DC were admitted as a state, it would elect two Democrat Senators to serve along with their Democrat Congressional delegate.